Гарвей (a_garvey) wrote,

About racism

There are two American movies with the same name divided in time by one century.
The classical film created by great director D.W. Griffith in 1915 and work of Nate Parker which was first time presented at Sundance Film Festival in January 2016.
First movie is included to US National Film Preservation Board in 1992. Second one got Audience Award in Sundance although in my opinion deserve Oscar much more than Moonlight.
Griffith's movie is justifying Ku Klux Klan. I wouldn't deny that events shown could be part of reality in American History of 19th century; but I do not believe that protection of innocent people was the only or even main reason for creating KKK: more realistic reason would be desire for revenge and keep of old order where rich Whites and suppressed Black Americans. And still: that film is highly estimated by movie professionals and was very popular in its time.
Parker's film shows another side of history: slave rebellion in Virginia in 1831. Thanks to director (who also wrote screenplay): he was honest and showed main character not totally positive, that makes Nat Turner look even higher. Notably it was not difficult to make scene of Turner's execution with extras' angry reaction: descendants of people killed during rebellion did not forget what has happened.

I wonder: would it be useful to show these two films next to each other to students in History lessons? With proper comments of course. Although: who knows what is proper comment in this case?
Tags: cinema, opinion

  • Из цикла "два подряд"

    У меня в ленте:

  • Вот так подрывается репутация.

    Если среди моих френдов есть френды Горького Лука, скажите ему, что на голосовании в ООН на место в Совбезе Канаде не хватило двадцати голосов, а не…

  • О книгах

    В комментариях к посту Митрича активно высказываются сторонники мнения о скором вымирании бумажных книг. Им отвечают, что в электронном виде есть…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded